Follow me on

RAS, Low-Carb Diets and NEAT



This morning, on the last day of the 2010 EASD in Stockholm, I co-chaired the Michael Berger debate on whether or not blocking the renin-angiotensin system is the be all and end all of organ protection. The debaters were Bo Feld-Rasmussen from the University of Copenhagen and Andrea Natali form the University of Pisa, Italy.

As is common in such debates the debaters ended up agreeing on most aspects of this question, barely agreeing to disagree on the 5% of aspects that remained controversial. Clearly, there is more to preventing end organ damage than simply blocking the renin angiotensin system – in fact, it may in the end not really matter all that much, how blood pressure is lowered after all, at least when it comes to protecting renal function in patients with type 2 diabetes.

Yesterday, as readers may recall, I gave an invited plenary lecture on my etiological assessment of obesity.

My talk, was immediately followed by Eric Wesman from Duke University, who talked about ketogenic low-carb diets, which he uses effectively for obesity treatment.

As Wesman explained, the principal rational for the use of low-carb diets is that they help reduce insulin levels, thereby allowing the body to access energy stores. As readers may recall, insulin is a potent “fat blocker” in that it not only promotes fat storage but also makes it more difficult for fat to be released from fat stores.

Thus in a randomised trial comparing a low-fat, a Mediterranean, and a low-carb diet, the latter resulted in the greatest weight loss, at least initiatlly. Furthermore, although participants may not have significantly differed in their weight loss at the end of a year, they low-carb participants appeared to have sustained imporvements in lipid status.

Several other studies have now also demonstrated that low-carb diets in patients with diabetes may result in better glycemic control.

Obviously, not everyone can follow these diets and therefore the average results seen in such studies may not be representative of the excellent results that Wesman sees in the patients who actually do manage to stay on these diets over time (remember: diets don’t work in people who don’t stick with them).

Thus, Wesman concludes that low-carb ketogenic diets are both feasible and effective for people who want to do them and can stick with them. But they obviously only works for people who truly enjoy cutting out their carbs – if this is perceived as a sacrifice or the temptation to eat carbs is too great (depression?) then it is obviously not the right diet for that person.

Wesman was followed by Jim Levine from the Mayo Clinic who published the original studies on the importance of non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT) as a key determinant of energy spent in every day living. Both feeding and immigration studies have shown that NEAT is an important factor that helps lean people regulate their body weight.

In his talk he discussed the various strategies that he (and his company) now uses to promote non-exercise activity like walking desks, walking meetings and other ways to (re-)introduce physical activity into everyday school and office life.

Thus, three very different talks on obesity in this session, covering the whole spectrum of individualised assessments and dietary intervention to physical activity.

AMS
Stockholm, Sweden

For more posts and comments follow me on FaceBook and Twitter

Shai I, Schwarzfuchs D, Henkin Y, Shahar DR, Witkow S, Greenberg I, Golan R, Fraser D, Bolotin A, Vardi H, Tangi-Rozental O, Zuk-Ramot R, Sarusi B, Brickner D, Schwartz Z, Sheiner E, Marko R, Katorza E, Thiery J, Fiedler GM, Blüher M, Stumvoll M, Stampfer MJ, & Dietary Intervention Randomized Controlled Trial (DIRECT) Group (2008). Weight loss with a low-carbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet. The New England journal of medicine, 359 (3), 229-41 PMID: 18635428

4 Comments

  1. It is hard to picture how this type of strict low carb diet would be a solution appropriate for the general population. All the cultures in the world have diets based on grains, such as corn, wheat, rice, etc. Recommending diets in the lower end of the DRI macronutrient range for carbohydrate, such as the south beach diet, may be more acceptable and would minimizes the negative side effects (see link by Dr. James Kenney) http://www.aims.edu/student/studentlife/resources/recipes/Low_carb.pdf

    Post a Reply
  2. Dr Sharma, thank you very much for all the great updates from EASD . I agree with you when you say “Clearly, there is more to preventing end organ damage than simply blocking the renin angiotensin system” but it gets confusing to me when you say “ – in fact, it may in the end not really matter all that much, how blood pressure is lowered after all, at least when it comes to protecting renal function in patients with type 2 diabetes”?
    If it really doesn’t matter much how we lower BP then how can the results of the many studies conducted to show the superiority of one class of antihypertensive over the other classes (e.g. RAS blockers vs B-blockers) and even one drug over other drugs in the same class (losartan vs Valsartan) in regards to better renal protection in patients with or without diabetes be explained?

    Post a Reply
  3. Interestingly, the study comparing the various diets reported 84.6% compliance at two years with the average weight loss in the low carb group (the most weight lost) was only 5.5kg.

    Either the dietary compliance was not as good as was presented or the calorie deficit was insufficient to produce a weight loss greater than 12 pounds over two years.

    Post a Reply
  4. yeah adam is appropriate. you cant just 1 day say yep
    im heading towards the fitness center and work out my biceps for that next
    four hours. no not gonna happen. requires a good deal time of training to build your self up to
    a schedule including jay’s. actually cant stand the men and women who jump to conclusions. oh he has large muscles, he is on steroids. no. do your homework ahead of you open your mouth. as a way to compete for mr. olympia, you are rigirously examined for steroids and drugs. additionally steroid users have insanely bloated stomachs and genuinely undesirable back again and thigh acne. muscletech makes some phenomenal products. find you an excellent stack and eat four to six effectively balanced meal with loads of protein and calories , you to can construct as much as a hardcore schedule like that.

    My web-site :: Brent

    Post a Reply

Leave a Reply to Mark Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *