Follow me on

Is Weight Stigma Making Us Fat?



sharma-obesity-weight-bias-conduit1Regular readers will be well aware of my concerns around the issues of weight stigma and anti-fat messaging and policies that blame, shame and otherwise bully those of us, who happen to be larger.

Apart from the emotional and economical toll, we are now seeing more and more evidence to support that notion that weight bias and discrimination have significant biological effects on metabolism.

Thus, a study by Natasha Schvey and colleagues from Yale University, published in Psychosomatic Medicine, shows that exposure to weight stigma can significantly increase cortisol secretion.

A 123 lean and overweight adult women were randomized to watching either a 10-minutes of a stigmatizing or neutral video.

The stigmatizing video consisted of a compilation of 24 brief clips from recent popular television shows and movies in which overweight and obese women were depicted in a pejorative manner, or portrayed in stereotypical ways (e.g., overeating, wearing ill-fitting clothing, struggling to exercise, dancing in a comical manner, etc). These clips were primarily taken from comedic films, situation comedies, or reality television shows, (e.g., The Biggest Loser, Drop Dead Diva, Say Yes to the Dress, Friends, etc) and are strongly representative of how obese individuals are depicted in film, television, and news media.

The neutral video depicted 20 emotionally neutral scenes such as clips about the invention of the radio, commercials for household products, car insurance, and so on.

Exposure to the stigmatizing video resulted in a marked increase in salivary cortisol levels (a marker of stress) compared to watching the neutral video.

Interestingly, the increase in cortisol was seen in both normal and overweight women.

Similarly, viewers of the stigmatizing video were more likely to feel upset, anxious, angry, and dislike the way that obese characters were portrayed and would prefer not to view media that depicts obese characters in this way.

Thus, as the authors report,

“…not only do women of all weight strata object to stigmatizing depictions of overweight and obese individuals, but also these negative depictions result in increased neuroendocrine stress as measured by salivary cortisol.”

“Given the high levels of media consumption among Americans, it is likely that millions of individuals are frequently exposed to weight-stigmatizing content that may promote neuroendocrine stress and subjective distress, signaling a public health concern. Finally, this study directly challenges recently proposed strategies to combat obesity with the use of stigma and negative social pressure. In fact, the present findings suggest that weight stigma may induce physiological stress and contribute to adverse health, thereby underscoring the importance of removing stigmatizing content from public health efforts to address obesity.”

As stress and negative emotional states are well-recognised risk factors for weight gain, the prevalence of stigmatizing messages about obesity should concern us all.

@DrSharma
Copenhagen, DK

ResearchBlogging.orgSchvey NA, Puhl RM, & Brownell KD (2014). The stress of stigma: exploring the effect of weight stigma on cortisol reactivity. Psychosomatic medicine, 76 (2), 156-62 PMID: 24434951

.

5 Comments

  1. The weight stigma also contributes to pressure to get weight off rapidly, which fuels the weight yo-yo cycle and diet industry which is all about the promise of rapid (not sustainable) weight loss.

    Post a Reply
  2. I feel compelled to make the obvious comment.
    If images of weight stigmatization cause weight promoting changes in our hormonal milieu, what about the relentless imaging of violence, terrorism, sexual abuse, etc, etc, etc that pervade our mass media and entertainment media? It seems a bit simplistic to focus on weight stigma when we have an entire culture of upsetting images to which we are overwhelmingly exposed. Do images of weight stimatization “signal a public health concern”? My guess is that they are only the tiniest tip of the iceberg.

    Post a Reply
    • Actually, the images you describe may perhaps also promote weight gain in those who find them upsetting (hopefully anyone who sees them). The point is that anything that increases emotional distress may well promote weight gain thorugh the metaolic alterations elicited by the stress response (e.g. higher levels of cortisol).

      Post a Reply
  3. Obesity is listed as a chronic medical condition on my doctor’s referral note for a scan of my liver. I am not that fat. I do have type II diabetes but it did not go away when I was 40 lbs lighter.I am 5’6″and weigh 206 at present and my bloodsugars are in the 200’s. Sure I should lose weight. But at 48 it’s not easy.
    I find anti-obesity messages to be discriminatory and negative employer policies toward obese individuals prevents me from seeking employment.

    Post a Reply
    • Your BMI is 33 so “technically” your doctor is correct – the current medical definition of obesity starts at a BMI of 30. You will find several posts on this site speaking to the problem with that definition.

      Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.